Understanding Peer-Review and Your Role as a Reviewer

Peer review is a fundamental process in scientific publishing that ensures the validity and quality of research. As a reviewer, you play a crucial role in this process by critically evaluating manuscripts to help editors determine their suitability for publication.
Understanding Peer-Review and Your Role as a Reviewer
Like

Share this post

Choose a social network to share with, or copy the URL to share elsewhere

This is a representation of how your post may appear on social media. The actual post will vary between social networks

Key aspects of your role as a reviewer include: 

  • Assessing the scientific merit and originality of the research 
  • Evaluating the methodology and data analysis 
  • Providing constructive feedback to help authors improve their work 
  • Recommending whether the manuscript is suitable for publication 

Karger employs single-blind peer for most journals, where you know the authors' identities but not vice versa. As a reviewer, you are expected to maintain confidentiality throughout the process and declare any potential conflicts of interest. 

To excel in your role, we encourage you to explore the resources available to enhance your reviewing skills and contribute effectively to the scientific process. Your role is vital in shaping the future of research and ensuring the integrity of scientific publications. 

Explore our resources 

  • What is peer review link 
  • Karger’s guidelines for reviewers link 
  • Karger's publication ethics and editorial policies link 
  • ICMJE recommendations link 
  • e-Learning: Peer review collection link 
  • Webinar: Reviewing for trust - Best practices for peer reviewers link 
  • Webinar: Promoting Reproducibility through peer review link